On the IQ of IE users and the spirit of the web

Last week there was a lot of news going around the claim that IE users had lower IQ than users of other web browsers. As soon as I heard the story I felt bad about peoples’ conclusions, and after it was announced to be fake, it confirmed it even more.

How “news” are created

First, looking at how fast it all caught on, that numerous news outlets reported about it and it made big headlines, it is both surprising and saddening how poor some fact-checking seem to be. I understand that it wasn’t “important” news that would change peoples’ lives, but it still is news.

News organizations have a responsibility that the things they report are indeed true, and if they start bending that rule, why would we give them the benefit of credibility to them in other cases? A recommendation for people working with news is to employ more critical thinking, just as they were taught to be in the first place, and investigate before they blindly republish.

The spirit of the web – about respecting users

The other part in this is the reason why probably so many believed it, is that they badly wanted it to be true. Lots of web developers have had grief developing for Internet Explorer over the years, and in some kind of misguided attempt to get even, they felt it would be ok to have a reason to disrespect the users of that web browsers.

And this is a really disconcerting issue. It is not the spirit of the web: the web is there for everyone! No matter what IQ level, gender, color of skin, background, level in the society, financial situation etc you have.

If we are serious in maintaining the most democratic medium we have gotten in the history of mankind, we need to start respecting each other and try to understand where people are coming from. Discuss things in a normal manner instead of resorting to name-calling, read the excellent advice on how to disagree if you need to discuss something, and be constructive and respectful in all interaction you have with your fellow humans.

Let’s make the web a good thing. For everyones’ sake.

Posted in Technology |

6 Comments

  • Tino Zijdel says:

    A “good thing” is about moral and ethics, but when big corporations are getting more and more influence on the web and when money can be gained we shall only see more of these “bad things” I’m afraid…

  • Robert Nyman says:

    Tino,

    It is a great risk indeed. One way to try to meet that, though, is that companies who treat their customers/users etc in a good way will get more customer loyalty and make better business, which will be incentive for them.

  • Willow says:

    Robert,

    I genuinely thought the original IQ article was a joke. Who could prove that sort of thing and retweeted it based on the fact that is was an amusingly silly idea. Imagine my surprise when the BBC put it up! I was not very surprised when they took it down again. But you’re right, they should be more careful to verify their facts. The fact that they could just blindly repost such an article is worrying at best.

    I like your points about the open web. People who genuinely believe such an article are getting in the way of openness and freedom. A threat to all we hold dear I think. Not through any vindictiveness mind but through the ignorance that holds people back.

    I’ll stop before I feel the need to write a big placard and march round London. But yes, excellent points. Great article :)

    Willow

  • Marco says:

    How about a study about the correlation between browser choice and arrogance?

  • Robert Nyman says:

    Willow,

    No London walk, just not yet. :-)
    And thanks!

    Marco,

    That’s just as risky. Let’s just settle for the fact that there all kinds of people, and they all deserve to take part of the web no matter which web browser, operating system, device etc they are using.

  • […] This post was Twitted by AjaLapus […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>